Echoes Corsac.net - Echoes camshot
lundi 29 octobre 2012 (1 post)

A friend of mine recently reminded me of the OpenPGP smartcard v2, and told me that it was perfectly able to handle 4096 bit RSA keys (provided you have GnuPG v2.0.18+). I had the opportunity to play with one a little, and notice it was super easy to use it for ssh authentication, especially since I already use gpg-agent as my ssh-agent (it should be easy to use a purely software authentication key as ssh key with GnuPG 2.1). So I decided to buy two of them and try to switch my main key (0x71ef0ba8) to it.

The cards arrived this weekend, and I was able to play with it a little. I didn't log every command I typed, but it was pretty easy, in the end. What I decided to do was to use one smartcard for every day usage, and one only for key signing. So basically, I would generate three (signing, encryption, authentication) subkeys, put them on smartcard 1, then put the primary key on smartcard 2. Then erase the private parts, and only keep them on smartcards.

In case it interests people, here the somehow detailed steps. Note that everywhere 'gpg' means 'gpg2' on Debian, we really need GnuPG v2 for correct smartcard handling. You'd better use gpg-agent too, although it doesn't seem mandatory.

  1. make a backup! As we're gonna play with private parts (!), it's always a good idea to have backups. And it'll be useful to have one later, in case there's a problem with the smartcards. You can do a copy of your complete ~/.gnupg folder, but I simply did:
    corsac@scapa: umask 066
    corsac@scapa: gpg -o 71ef0ba8.gpg --export-secret-keys 71ef0ba8
    
  2. Add three subkeys. Skip this is you already have subkeys (you usually already have an encryption subkey, but I wanted to switch to a new one too) --expert is needed in order to chose capabilities.
    corsac@scapa: gpg --expert --edit-key 71ef0ba8
    gpg> addkey
    Please select what kind of key you want:
       (3) DSA (sign only)
       (4) RSA (sign only)
       (5) Elgamal (encrypt only)
       (6) RSA (encrypt only)
       (7) DSA (set your own capabilities)
       (8) RSA (set your own capabilities)
    Your selection? 8
    
    Possible actions for a RSA key: Sign Encrypt Authenticate 
    Current allowed actions: Sign Encrypt 
    
       (S) Toggle the sign capability
       (E) Toggle the encrypt capability
       (A) Toggle the authenticate capability
       (Q) Finished
    
    Your selection? e
    
    Possible actions for a RSA key: Sign Encrypt Authenticate 
    Current allowed actions: Sign 
    
       (S) Toggle the sign capability
       (E) Toggle the encrypt capability
       (A) Toggle the authenticate capability
       (Q) Finished
    
    Your selection? Q
    RSA keys may be between 1024 and 4096 bits long.
    What keysize do you want? (2048) 
    Requested keysize is 2048 bits
    Please specify how long the key should be valid.
             0 = key does not expire
            = key expires in n days
          w = key expires in n weeks
          m = key expires in n months
          y = key expires in n years
    Key is valid for? (0) 1y
    Key expires at dim. 27 oct. 2013 20:38:44 CET
    Is this correct? (y/N) y
    Really create? (y/N) y
    We need to generate a lot of random bytes. It is a good idea to perform
    some other action (type on the keyboard, move the mouse, utilize the
    disks) during the prime generation; this gives the random number
    generator a better chance to gain enough entropy.
    
    Repeat this for encryption and authentication subkeys. Then save and send the key to keyservers
    gpg> save
    corsac@scapa: gpg --send-keys 71ef0ba8
    
  3. Next, we'll switch to the smartcard part. I use a Gemalto PC ExpressCard reader which is perfectly recognized under Debian. You just need few tools:
    root@scapa: ~# apt-get install pcscd scdaemon
    
    Plug the reader, insert the card, make sure it's detected:
    corsac@scapa: gpg --card-status
    Application ID ...: D2760001240102000005000016A10000
    Version ..........: 2.0
    Manufacturer .....: ZeitControl
    ...
    
    You can edit various parameter (name etc.) and change the PINs using gpg:
    corsac@scapa: gpg --change-pin
    corsac@scapa: gpg --card-edit
    
  4. Then we'll put the subkeys in the first smartcard. It might be a good idea to export again the private keys for backups.
    corsac@scapa: gpg -o 71ef0ba8.gpg --export-secret-keys 71ef0ba8
    
  5. We'll now use the keytocard gpg command to move the private parts on the smartcard:
    corsac@scapa: gpg --edit-key 71ef0ba8
    gpg> key 1 # select encryption subkey
    gpg> keytocard
    gpg> key 2 # select signature subkey
    gpg> keytocard
    gpg> key 3 # select authentication subkey
    gpg> keytocard
    gpg> save
    
    A quick check on the card now reveals that it's populated:
    corsac@scapa: gpg --card-status
    Application ID ...: D2760001240102000005000016A10000
    Version ..........: 2.0
    Manufacturer .....: ZeitControl
    Serial number ....: 000016A1
    Name of cardholder: Yves-Alexis Perez
    Language prefs ...: fr
    Sex ..............: unspecified
    URL of public key : http://www.corsac.net/71ef0ba8.asc
    Login data .......: corsac
    Signature PIN ....: forced
    Key attributes ...: 2048R 2048R 2048R
    Max. PIN lengths .: 32 32 32
    PIN retry counter : 3 3 3
    Signature counter : 7
    Signature key ....: 9745 B022 7323 81FE 9E7E  AFF5 6DDB 53F2 A675 C0A5
          created ....: 2012-10-27 11:24:07
    Encryption key....: F7E0 078F EA1A 5F23 92E0  20B3 A83A D136 D98D 0D9F
          created ....: 2012-10-27 11:27:01
    Authentication key: 8CFD D478 AB4A 16F8 F0EC  CD33 24E2 3B5C CC0E 273D
          created ....: 2012-10-17 14:29:18
    General key info..: pub  2048R/A675C0A5 2012-10-27 Yves-Alexis Perez 
    sec>  4096R/71EF0BA8  created: 2009-05-06  expires: never     
                          card-no: 0005 000016A2
    ssb   4096g/36E31BD8  created: 2009-05-06  expires: never     
    ssb>  2048R/CC0E273D  created: 2012-10-17  expires: 2013-10-27
                          card-no: 0005 000016A1
    ssb>  2048R/A675C0A5  created: 2012-10-27  expires: 2013-10-27
                          card-no: 0005 000016A1
    ssb>  2048R/D98D0D9F  created: 2012-10-27  expires: 2013-10-27
                          card-no: 0005 000016A1
    
  6. At that point, the private part is replaced by a stub in the secret keyring, so when you export them, you only export stubs which you can then use anywhere without actually giving your private key. So now is a good idea to export the subkeys so you can import them on other boxes:

    corsac@scapa: gpg -o 71ef0ba8-subkeys.gpg --export-secret-subkeys 71ef0ba8
    

    Note that only the subkeys private parts have been moved to the card, not the primary one, so you're still able to sign keys. Here, you have multiple choices. You can simply erase the private key (and later re-import the stubs) and use the offline copy made above when you need to sign another key.

  7. What I did is something else. I've put the primary key on my second OpenPGP smartcard. That way, I won't lose it, it'll be kept safely in my house, but still be on a hardware token where it won't come out.

    The procedure for doing is so is exactly the same as above. First take a backup (in case you didn't do it first, do it now since after the keytocard command you won't have a backup of your primary key and there'll be no way to extract it from the smartcard. Then put the new smartcard in the reader, edit the key (don't select a subkey) and run the keytocard command.

    After that, running gpg --export-secret-keys will export the stub and not the private part of your primary key.

In the end, it seems that everything is running fine. Only issue is that scdaemon is sometime not behaving nicely (especially after a card change or or suspend/resume cycle). I didn't yet report a bug but you might want to kill it in case it's stuck.

You can also use the authentication subkey for ssh logins. When the card is inserted, the authentication subkey appears automatically (through the magic of gpg-agent):

corsac@scapa: ssh-add -L
ssh-rsa AAAAB3NzaC1yc2EA... cardno:0005000016A1

And now you can add it to your various authorized_keys and use the smartcard for SSH.

Yves-Alexis@23:19:10 (Debian)

Images
Stats
  • 1526 posts
  • 7960 jours
  • 0.19 posts/jour
  • IRC
  • Last.fm
Stuff
Tech
Weblogs
Desktop